Commissioned by Not Performing: Why Mining and Metals Assets Struggle During Ramp-up
Commissioning may mark the completion of a project, but it doesn’t guarantee an operation is ready to perform. Learn why mining and metals assets often struggle during ramp-up and how an owner-led, evidence-based approach can help protect value. Discover how a more intentional approach to ramp-up can help set operations up for long-term success.
Completing commissioning does not demonstrate that a new operation can deliver its investment case. Whether the operation can deliver its investment case is established during start-up and ramp-up, when the owner must convert a technically complete asset into a safe, stable and self-sustaining operation.
Production below plan defers revenue, consumes working capital and prolongs dependence on project teams, equipment vendors and contractors. In North America, constrained labor markets, remote logistics, seasonal conditions and regulatory and stakeholder commitments can increase this exposure.
Our view is that ramp-up should be managed as an owner-led, evidence-based progression. Production should increase only when the current operating stage is stable and the organization has demonstrated that it can manage the risks and complexity associated with the next stage.
Commissioning demonstrates that the asset has been installed and tested. Ramp-up demonstrates that the operating organization can safely and sustainably manage it under actual production conditions.
Our Point of View
Ramp-up should be managed according to four principles:
Evidence before progression. Completion of actions, documents and training is not sufficient unless people, equipment and operating systems can perform under actual conditions.
Safety and production managed together. Effective control of activity-based and process risks is a condition of increasing production or operating complexity.
One integrated operating plan. Production, maintenance, workforce, contractor, supply-chain and external requirements should be managed through a common plan and operating rhythm.
Capability matched to the phase. Start-up requires risk recognition, troubleshooting and abnormal-condition management. Stable operation requires repeatable systems, reliability and continuous improvement.
The value at risk during ramp-up
First production does not establish that the asset is delivering its investment case.
McNulty’s review of 81 mineral-processing plant ramp-ups found that only 23, or 28%, followed the best-performing Series 1A ramp-up profile. The remaining operations experienced slower or less stable production development. The causes included differences in process maturity, design, equipment, feed characteristics and operating performance.
The study nevertheless demonstrates the variability in the path from first production and achievement of sustained design performance.
Ore variability, equipment reliability, weather and technology maturity can affect ramp-up. Where these factors are reasonably foreseeable, the ramp-up plan should define how the operation will detect, control and respond to them. If foreseeable variation repeatedly destabilizes production, the operation has not yet demonstrated the control or capability required for that condition.
Value is realized only when saleable output can be sustained at the required rate, quality and cost.
Common causes of start-up delays and unstable ramp-up
Unstable ramp-up is rarely the result of one technical failure. It generally reflects interactions between the asset, operating organization and pressure to progress. Three recurring conditions are typically present.
- The asset is not yet operating as an integrated system: Equipment, process design, ore characteristics, control systems, maintenance strategies, operating data and supporting infrastructure may function individually but not yet operate reliably together. Problems that were not apparent during commissioning can emerge when the full operation is placed under sustained production conditions.
- The operating organization is not yet self-sufficient: Roles may be filled and training completed, but the operation may still depend on a limited number of experienced personnel, equipment vendors, contractors or project-team members to diagnose problems and make decisions. Canadian labor-market evidence illustrates this constraint: five of six indicators monitored by the Mining Industry Human Resources Council continued to signal a tight mining labor market in 2024.
- Production advances faster than control and capability: Schedule or commercial pressure may lead the operation to increase throughput, fleet size, shifts or operating complexity before equipment, critical controls, workforce capability and management systems are stable at the current level. Remote logistics, extreme weather, supply-chain limitations and regulatory, Indigenous, community and customer commitments may introduce further dependencies that need to be incorporated into the ramp-up plan.
These conditions indicate that the operation is not yet managing the asset, organization and operating environment as one system.